Research on Smith Machine Squat · Every study we found · How we choose studies

Smith Machine Squat: someone doing the move
A lab study · healthy adultsModerate evidence

Checked automatically against the study

Free-weight squats made leg muscles work harder than Smith machine squats.

Muscles worked 43% harder overall in the free-weight squat than in the Smith machine squat

This was a small, one-off lab test with just six healthy people. They did one set of 8 reps of each squat while sensors on the skin measured how hard muscles worked. Calves, the back of the thighs and the inner front thigh worked harder in the free-weight squat. It measured muscle effort, not muscle growth.

Who took partSix healthy people. The abstract doesn't say their sex, age or training experience.LimitsOnly six people took part.It measured muscle effort in one session, not growth over time.

Why this bandA one-off lab test of 6 peopleAbout this exercise: it’s in the titleAmong the top 2% most cited papers of its age

What it means in practice
  • Add free-weight squats alongside Smith squats if you want your calves and thighs to work harder.
  • Use the Smith machine when you want a more guided squat with less balance demand.
Kind of study
A lab study
People
healthy adults
What they looked at
Muscle activity

Original title: A comparison of free weight squat to Smith machine squat using electromyography

Schwanbeck S, Chilibeck PD, Binsted G · Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research · Tue Dec 1 2009 · DOI 10.1519/jsc.0b013e3181b1b181

Free-weight squats made leg muscles work harder than Smith machine squats. · Smith Machine Squat research · Body CEO