Which part of the hamstring does each exercise use?
When you pick a hamstring exercise, you probably pick by feel or habit. You rarely ask which part of the muscle is doing the most work.
Your hamstrings are not a single block. This review looked at the semitendinosus on the inner back of the thigh and the biceps femoris on the outer back.
The researchers searched PubMed, Web of Science and Scopus up to 31 August 2024. They kept studies of healthy adults that measured both muscles during hamstring exercises. The abstract doesn't say how many studies were found or included.
The pooled analysis covered 619 people. Each study used sensors on the skin, called EMG, to pick up the electrical signal from each muscle. Activity was shown as a share of each person's maximal voluntary contraction, which is the hardest they could squeeze that muscle on purpose.
The answer changed by exercise
Across all the knee-based and hip-based exercises together, the review found no significant difference between the muscles. Taken as a whole, neither muscle led.
But single exercises told different stories. During kettlebell swings, the inner hamstring showed more activity than the outer. The standardized mean difference, or SMD, was -0.59 (p = 0.0007).
An SMD states a gap in units of spread, so studies that measured things differently can be pooled. The minus sign here means the inner muscle was higher. A gap of this size is usually called medium.
The swing did not win everywhere. In back extensions, another hip-based exercise, the outer hamstring was higher (SMD 0.34, p = 0.0092). The Nordic hamstring exercise favored the inner muscle (SMD -0.33, p = 0.01). Prone-lying curls favored the outer muscle (SMD 0.94, p = 0.0076).
So the question of which hamstring a move works has no single answer. It depends on the exercise.
What this means for you
If you swing a kettlebell, your inner hamstring probably gets a bit more of the work than your outer one. That fits healthy adults in these studies. It may not fit everyone, and the abstract doesn't say who was tested.
Higher activity during a set is not the same as more muscle or strength later. This review didn't measure either. It's a poor reason to choose or drop swings on its own.
Body CEO's suggestion, not something the study tested: pick swings because you like the hip-hinge movement and it suits your goals. If you want variety across your hamstrings, mix hip-based and knee-based exercises. The results here lean in different directions for different moves.
Your goals, your equipment and how a movement feels still decide most of this. If you have pain or a health concern, talk with a qualified professional before changing your training.
- It measured how hard muscles work, not muscle growth or strength.
- The authors say the studies measured muscle work in different ways, so firm conclusions are hard to draw.
- The abstract doesn't say how many studies were pooled.
What this review can't answer
The biggest gap is the link between activity and results. A training study that followed people for a long time, and measured muscle size or strength in each hamstring, would be needed to see if a higher EMG reading leads to more growth.
The measurement is also shaky. The authors say studies recorded and processed EMG in different ways. A set of studies using a single agreed method would show whether the swing result holds up.
Finally, the abstract doesn't describe the people. Whether the swing finding is the same for women and men, for beginners and experienced lifters, or for light and heavy bells is still open.
The numbers behind the headline
Each row compares the inner hamstring (semitendinosus, ST) with the outer hamstring (biceps femoris, BF). The SMD sign shows the winner: negative means ST was higher, positive means BF was higher. A bigger number, ignoring the sign, means a bigger gap.
| Exercise | Higher activity | SMD | p-value |
|---|---|---|---|
| Kettlebell swing | Inner (ST) | -0.59 | 0.0007 |
| Back extension | Outer (BF) | 0.34 | 0.0092 |
| Nordic hamstring exercise | Inner (ST) | -0.33 | 0.01 |
| Prone-lying curl | Outer (BF) | 0.94 | 0.0076 |
| All knee- and hip-based exercises together | No significant difference | Not given | Not given |
These are differences in muscle activity during an exercise, measured on the skin, in 619 healthy adults. They are not measures of growth, strength or results over time. The authors say varied EMG methods make it hard to say whether any exercise truly favors one hamstring muscle.
Written with Ronan Diego, Head of Health Programs at Mindvalley, Certified Mindvalley Coach. Written in our own words from the study’s abstract: the full paper isn’t open to read.
Body CEO educational article · Editorial review pending · Updated Sun Nov 22
This page explains research for general wellness. It isn’t personal training or medical advice.