Burpees or sprints for eight minutes a session?
Some days you have almost no time. You can skip the workout, or you can do something very short and very hard. If you pick the short and hard option, does the move you choose matter?
A team of researchers tested that. They compared two time-matched programs of about 8 minutes per session. One used sprints. The other used burpees. The sessions had the same pattern: 10 all-out efforts of 4 seconds each, with 30 seconds of recovery between them.
Forty-three active, healthy adults took part. That was 31 men and 12 women, about 27 years old on average. They were assigned by chance to sprint interval training (15 people), burpee interval training (15 people), or a control group that did no extra training (13 people).
The two training groups did 5 days of sessions. Before and after, the researchers measured jump height, a 10-meter sprint, a shuttle run test, body composition, blood pressure and more. They also asked about confidence and intention to keep exercising.
Each program improved a different skill
The burpee group got better at the countermovement jump. That is a standing jump where you dip down and then leap as high as you can. The change was statistically significant (p = 0.0014, d = 0.72).
The sprint group did not improve its jump in the same way. It improved its distance on the shuttle run test, a back-and-forth running test (p = 0.03, d = 0.62). So the same plan with a different move gave a different result.
Two terms help here. The p-value tells you how likely a result like this would be if chance alone were at work, and a smaller number means less likely. The d value is an effect size. It shows how big a change is, and a bigger d means a bigger change.
Sprints felt harder. They produced a higher share of peak heart rate, more energy use and a higher effort rating than burpees. Even so, confidence in sticking with the plan dropped more for the sprint group as sessions piled up. That gap showed up at the five-times-a-week frequency (p = 0.040, d = 0.79). Intention to keep exercising did not differ between the groups.
Several things did not change in either training group. These were body composition, blood pressure, the 10-meter sprint, estimated aerobic fitness and autonomic measures (the body's automatic heart-rate control).
What this means for you
If you are short on time and want to jump higher, a few very short burpee intervals fit that goal. They also need no equipment. If you care more about running performance, sprint intervals matched that goal better in this study.
Body CEO's suggestion, which the study did not test, is to match the drill to the skill you want. Burpees are a jumping and full-body move. Sprints are a running move. Pick the one that looks like the thing you want to get better at.
Personal preference matters too. Sprints were harder, and the sprint group's confidence slipped more over the sessions. A plan you will keep doing may beat one that is harder on paper.
This evidence applies to active, healthy adults around 27. It doesn't tell us about beginners, older adults or people with health conditions. All-out efforts are demanding, so ease in and check with a qualified professional if you are unsure.
- Small groups of about 15 people each.
- A very short program of only a few days.
- Body fat, blood pressure and 10-metre sprint didn't change in either group.
What this study can't answer
The program lasted only five days, with two training groups of 15 people each. We don't know if the jump gain grows, holds or fades over weeks or months. Only a longer study could show that.
We also don't know whether the pattern holds in other people. The group was mostly men, young and already active. A study with more women, older adults or newer exercisers would be needed.
Finally, the study found no change in body composition, blood pressure or the 10-meter sprint. That may be because the program was so short. It does not show that these intervals can never move those measures.
The measurements, side by side
Each row is one measure. The abstract names which group came out ahead but gives few sizes, so the table shows only the numbers it reports. SIT is sprint interval training and BIT is burpee interval training.
| Measure | Which group came out ahead | Reported statistics |
|---|---|---|
| Countermovement jump height | BIT improved significantly | p = 0.0014, d = 0.72 |
| Shuttle run test distance | SIT improved significantly | p = 0.03, d = 0.62 |
| Share of peak heart rate, energy use, effort rating | Higher in SIT than BIT | p < 0.05 |
| Self-efficacy (confidence) | Worsened more for SIT than BIT as sessions increased | p = 0.040, d = 0.79 at the five-times-a-week frequency |
| Intention to keep exercising | No difference between groups | p > 0.05 |
| Body composition, blood pressure, 10-meter sprint, estimated aerobic fitness, autonomic measures | No change with training | p > 0.05 |
Group sizes were small, at 15, 15 and 13 people. The abstract gives no jump heights in centimeters, so a significant result here doesn't tell you how big the gain felt in real life.
Written with Ronan Diego, Head of Health Programs at Mindvalley, Certified Mindvalley Coach. Written in our own words from the study’s abstract: the full paper isn’t open to read.
Body CEO educational article · Editorial review pending · Updated Sun Nov 22
This page explains research for general wellness. It isn’t personal training or medical advice.