What research says

3 studies · summaries checked against each study · How we choose studies
Dumbbell Fly: someone doing the move
1A lab study · active menModerate evidence

Checked automatically against the study

Doing flyes on a Swiss ball didn't change how hard your muscles worked.

About the same muscle activity in 14 men with unusual shoulder blade movement and 14 without

This lab test had 28 active men. Half had shoulder blades that move in an unusual way, and half didn't, and none had symptoms. They did the bench press and the fly with a light weight, on a bench and on a Swiss ball. Sensors on the skin measured how hard the muscles worked. Both groups were about the same, and the Swiss ball made little difference.

Who took part28 physically active men; no women; the abstract doesn't say their ageLimitsMen only.A light weight, in one session.It measured how hard muscles worked, not strength or growth.

Why this bandA one-off lab test of 28 peopleAbout this exercise: it’s in the titleAmong the top 12% most cited papers of its age

What it means in practice
  • Do your flyes on a normal bench, because a Swiss ball didn't make your muscles work harder here.
Kind of study
A lab study
People
active men
What they looked at
Muscle activity

Original title: Activation of upper limb muscles in subjects with scapular dyskinesis during bench-press and dumbbell fly on stable and unstable surfaces

Sousa DSF, de Farias WM, de Amorim Batista G and others · Journal of Back and Musculoskeletal Rehabilitation · Sat Jan 1 2022 · DOI 10.3233/bmr-210243

Dumbbell Fly: someone doing the move
2A lab study · young men who liftModerate evidenceFree to read

Checked automatically against the study

The bench press worked the chest harder than the dumbbell fly did.

Chest, front shoulder and triceps worked 8 to 81% harder in the bench press than in the fly

This was a single-session lab test with 17 men who had lifted for years. Sensors on the skin measured how hard each muscle worked. The chest, the front of the shoulder and the triceps all worked harder in the bench press than in the fly. The biceps worked harder in the fly.

Who took part17 trained men, about 22.9 years old on average, with about 4.8 years of lifting; no womenLimitsA small group of men only.It measured how hard muscles worked in a single session, not muscle growth over time.

Why this bandA one-off lab test of 17 peopleAbout this exercise: it’s in the titlePeople who already trainAmong the top 13% most cited papers of its age

What it means in practice
  • Make a press, like the bench press, your main chest move, and add the fly as an extra.
  • Use the fly when you want to train your arms out wide with straight elbows.
Kind of study
A lab study
People
young men who lift
What they looked at
Muscle activity

Original title: A Comparison of Muscle Activation between Barbell Bench Press and Dumbbell Flyes in Resistance-Trained Males

Solstad TE, Andersen V, Shaw M and others · Journal of Sports Science & Medicine · Thu Nov 19 2020 · PubMed 33239937

Dumbbell Fly: someone doing the move
3A lab study · young experienced liftersModerate evidenceFree to read

Checked automatically against the study

Weights gave higher peak force than air resistance in a fly like the Dumbbell Fly.

Peak force was much higher with weights in all 4 lifts, including the fly. Average force in the fly was about the same (20 people, 8 reps each).

This was a small lab test with 20 experienced lifters in one session. They did a fly like the Dumbbell Fly and other lifts, once with weights and once with air-powered machine resistance. A sensor measured how hard they pushed while lifting. Peak force was much higher with weights, but average force in the fly was about the same.

Who took part20 experienced lifters, with an average age of 21.9 years. The abstract doesn't say whether women took part.LimitsSmall group of 20 people.One lab session measuring force, not strength or muscle gains over weeks.The abstract doesn't say the fly was done with dumbbells.

Why this bandA one-off lab test of 20 peopleTests this exercisePeople who already trainIn a recognised free-to-read journal (DOAJ)

Kind of study
A lab study
People
young experienced lifters
What they looked at
Performance

Original title: Force Profile Characteristics of Gravitational and Pneumatic Resistances in Pull and Push Exercises

Barba-Ruiz M, Heredia-Elvar JR, Martín-Castellanos A, Iglesias-García J, Hermosilla-Perona F · Sports (Basel, Switzerland) · Tue Jul 22 2025 · DOI 10.3390/sports13080239

How studies shape Body CEO

Every summary here is checked against its study before it appears: the numbers come from the study, with no promises. 316 studies in use, across 97 exercises, and this one was last checked for new research on Fri Nov 13 2026. How we review research

  1. 1 · FoundOn PubMed, checked for retractions
  2. 2 · WeighedScored Strong, Moderate or Early
  3. 3 · ReadPut in plain words, every number checked
  4. 4 · Shapes your planStrong and Moderate takeaways guide sets, reps and rest
  5. 5 · Eliza cites itReads our approved studies first, with the study linked
← Back to Dumbbell Fly